Friday, January 1, 2010

Dutch Square Mall: Columbia, SC

I hope everyone had a great holiday! I took a much needed break from posting, but am back to start the new year right with a new post, new mall and new city!

Childhood memories of malls by and large involved Georgia malls for me, but there is one notable exception: Dutch Square Mall.  In time, I have attempted to learn more about this mall that remained vaguely in my memories for years since I briefly called Columbia home.  At the time, I lived in West Columbia close to Columbiana Mall, but the year was 1986 and Columbiana was still in the planning stages.  Because of that, Dutch Square was still very much the place to shop in the Irmo/West Columbia area, which has remained one of the fastest growing and most prosperous areas of Columbia since the time I lived there 23 years ago.  However, Dutch Square itself has changed considerably as the neighborhoods around it have aged and competition has marginalized it while the mall itself has changed little in layout since it was built.


Dutch Square was first built in 1969 as the second major shopping mall in the state.  That seems laughable today with only 650,000 square feet of retail space, but in fact Dutch Square is actually amazing on how it survived as the smallest regional mall in a city that evolved into having four regional shopping malls.  I reason that loyalty means a lot, because while it is an ailing mall it survived 20 years past the opening of Columbiana only four exits up I-26.  To me, one of the most interesting things about the mall today is the fact that it is built on top of a hill with a constant slope through the mall.  In fact, the slope in the mall is some places uneven enough it almost makes me wonder if the place sunk at some point.  What is also interesting, though, is the keystone Belk store at the mall, which opened as Augusta-based J.B. White.  This was no ordinary White's, either, featuring three levels of merchandise.  At the time it was built, it was Columbia's second suburban White's location.  Unfortunately, Belk closed the third level not long after taking over the store in 1998.


Pictures do not do adequate justice showing the constant slopes through the mall.  I am not quite sure why they felt the need to build ramped sections all through the mall like that.  Columbiana and the Richway malls were like that, too.  The first photo is of the center court area.

 

Front main entrance corridor.  The doors on the front look straight-up 1969, but the renovations have toned it down a bit.  This mall was extremely dark in the 80's.

Dutch Square also contained one of three locations of Columbia-based Tapp's, an upscale department store that formed the opposite end of the mall from White's.  More distinct, though, was the third anchor of the mall, a Woolco discount store flanking the south side of the mall.  The mall also contained a two-level Annabelle's restaurant, though I have no recollection of where this was at or when it closed.  I know it was still operational as late as 1990, because I ate there with my parents and some friends of the family.  I recall it outside of an anchor, so I'm presuming White's.  In the last visit, I saw a big empty junior anchor next to Belk, but it looked more to be the size of a Goody's or McCrory's in lieu of the restaurant I remember.  Due to its vintage, the mall also has many stores with both interior and exterior entrances mostly on the front of the mall.


AMC Theaters flank the east end of the mall, which was the mall entrance to Tapp's for most of its existance.  That kid there seemed very odd sitting there just staring by himself.  Who lets their kids do that anymore?  This place probably won't still be standing when he gets to be my age...if he actually does.


Entrance to Burlington Coat Factory, previously Woolco and Brendle's.  Woolco anchored malls typically did not do well, but this was not the focus of the mall nor its strength.  This Burlington Coat Factory arrived around 1999 after Brendle's closed in the same location.  Brendle's and Office Depot subdivided the location much in the way they did Sky City at Innsbruck Mall in Asheville.


Belk has been on a spree lately renovating their mall entrances.  I absolutely hate it when they do that, too.  I wonder what this looked like when White's was still there.

Dutch Square was relatively small, but it had help across I-26 on the same Bush River Road with Bush River Mall, a much smaller mall anchored by Kroger and Richway.  Bush River opened eight years after Dutch Square opened, but its small size and discount anchors were never a threat to the mall.  This meant that anything that couldn't fit into Dutch Square could find space across the interstate, and the two malls complimented each other for years resulting in a red-hot retail corridor throughout the 1970's and 1980's.  The mall at first had no competition until Columbia Place opened in 1978.  However, .the location of Columbia Place completely across the city maintained a balance that had no effect on the mall.


A view from Burlington Coat Factory to the back entrance.  A built-in makeshift food court flanks the court ahead.  To the right is AMC and to the left is the long haul to Belk.

 

 

Looking toward the back entrance at the food court area (first photo) and back into the food court (second photo).  A Chinese restaurant is to my right.

In these successful years, only one major change occurred as third anchor Woolco went bankrupt in 1983, which was quickly absorbed by catalog merchant Brendle's and Office Depot, which subdivided the store.  As a result, Office Depot had no connection to the interior mall.  Office Depot may have previously been an A&P since information I ran across suggested it was at the mall in the 80's.  The prominent position of Dutch Square changed, though, when Columbiana Center opened in Irmo a few exits up in 1990 after two decades of dominance.  Richland Fashion Mall also opened a year prior, but its unique positioning and anchor line-up did not have as much of an impact as Columbiana.


Looking back at center court from the other direction.  As empty as it was looking in this photo, it is strange to realize how swamped this mall was as late as 1989.

Columbiana Center did not seem to have a dramatic effect on Dutch Square right away.  Uniquely, the two malls actually at first looked like they would compliment each other.  The only anchors the two malls shared were White's, and White's thankfully decided never to close their three-story store at Dutch Square.  In fact, it looked like the mall's fortunes may actually have begun to improve at that point.  That is because in 1990 the downtown Macy's, which was a legacy Atlanta-based Davison's, was looking to move from downtown to Dutch Square complete with an expansion.  As the old downtown Macy's store prepared to close, the plans were set to build a larger three level, 220,000 square feet Macy's at Dutch Square complete with an expansion.  The plans were set in 1992 to have the store opened by the following year, making Dutch Square a tough contender in the market.  Unfortunately, something happened and the project never came to fruition.  It should be noted that at the same time, RH Macy Co. was preparing to go bankrupt only to be "saved" by then-Federated Department Stores, which operates Macy's of today.  Federated Department Stores, which already owned then-Rich's at Columbia Place, was apparently uninterested in building at the mall.


A look at the second back wing containing Piccadilly Cafeteria.

 

Piccadilly Cafeteria opened as Morrison's and was converted to Piccadilly when Morrison's was purchased in 1995.

The 1990's saw many changes at the mall.  First was the bankruptcy of Tapp's in fall of 1995.  This closure left an obvious void at the mall, which was not left vacant for long.  Instead of waiting to bring in Macy's or another department store, the owners simply demolished the Tapp's and rebuilt the location as an AMC theater.  In the late 90's, Annabelle's left the mall as well.  The next change was in 1998 when Belk acquired the White's location at the mall in lieu of Dillard's, who had just bought out White's.  Last was the arrival of Burlington Coat Factory in 1999 after Brendle's went bankrupt in 1995.  Burlington Coat Factory left flagging Bush River Mall to join the mall.  Ironically, Burlington Coat Factory absorbed many of the prime Woolco locations in the early 1980's and still operates in many of those old Woolco stores today so even though they arrived late it was a natural fit.. This swap was because Dillard's sought other locations owned by Belk at that point.  This was for the best, because Belk at the mall has remained a draw.  The mall also was renovated in that time period, losing its 1970's trappings such as the dark linoleum tiles.  The Belk, however, has apparently not changed at all, still maintaining the same appearance as when it operated as White's.  Considering the colorless, boring remodels of today, that is actually somewhat pleasing to see.


Dutch Square, plain and simple.  Macy's, they need you here.  You promised them.


Looking down the mall toward Belk.  It always puzzles me why if a mall is ailing, the emptiest part of the mall is the Belk wing.  The whole mall tilts downhill toward Belk.  Hopefully that's nothing symbolic.

Twenty years after Columbiana Center opened, Dutch Square amazingly lingers on.  Bush River Mall, near the mall, has long since died and been demolished, now operating as a nearly new Wal-Mart despite the fact the area around the mall is looking somewhat empty.  The redevelopment of that site has undoubtedly been helpful since anchor Target left to join the retail explosion around Columbiana Center.  Regardless, the fact is that Dutch Square has an excellent location just southeast of the intersection of I-20 and I-26.  Indeed, the mall today is looking emptier than past visits with a relatively high level of vacancies.  However, the fact that the mall is the oldest in the city and has survived after being eclipsed by two other malls says that it has definite staying power.


White's in general had a very distinct way of doing escalators.  The down escalator was staggered slightly offset and thus lower than the up escalator, and they ran side by side.  While this works in two level stores, I can see this was problematic for this store, which operated three levels under White's.  The lights above suggest those upper escalators, but when I came up to them, I could see they were clearly walled off.  A dark third level in a store is always creepy.


On the outside, White's stores built in the 70's were stately but dirt plain.  This store featured the older elegant script "White's" logo in lieu of the "J.B. WHITE" in skinny black letters found on the last generation stores.

The owners should remember what almost happened in 1993 with Macy's as well as the fact that they are holding ground in an over-malled environment.  Perhaps they should consider expanding the mall again, tearing down a nearby shopping center and building a multi-level expansion.  Columbia still only has one Macy's location, and the one currently operational is in a struggling mall.  Since only two of four malls in the city are likely to survive, it is my hope that Macy's will consider joining either this mall or Richland in lieu of other horizons.  Now would be the opportunity to lure in Macy's as well as a few other stores under-represented in the area to keep Columbiana and the new lifestyle center on the other side of town from completely dominating the Columbia retail scene.  Perhaps Burlington Coat Factory should be replaced by a Borders Books and some new stores introduced into the market at the mall.  Dutch Square Mall turned 40 years old last year, so it deserves some attention after serving the city longer than any other mall.


 

I am betting these were renovated original signs, because signs this tall are typically not allowed today.   As you can see, the front highway sign lists all the major stores...well almost.  I do not recall where West Marine was in the mall.  I think listing Piccadilly Cafeteria would have been preferable to the dubious "Super China Buffet".  I'm guessing Super China Buffet was previously a sign for Annabelle's.  Maybe that's why Macy's opted out.


Never dare to let the mall entrance retain a vintage look...at least in mall management world.  This 90's stucco monstrosity is supposed to fool you into thinking this mall is not as old as it looks.  It usually takes more than a facelift to bring a person back to youthful beauty, and likewise it usually takes more than a stucco entrance blob to hide the real age of a mall.  The problem is, plastic surgery is a lot cheaper than a major mall overhaul.  Is this the equivalent of mall botox?


Luckily, the front side (or back?) doesn't go as overboard with the stucco.  I really like the stores with the outside entrances.  You typically find that in the oldest malls, and I think it casts a positive light on the mall.  Note Belk/White's in the background.


Burlington Coat Factory, an anchor to the mall since 1999 opened as Woolco, which went bankrupt in late 1982.  The store was subdivided in the 1980's between Brendle's and another store, which is today Office Depot.  Burlington Coat Factory absorbed the location in 1999.  The small vertical grooves in the brick are a dead giveaway of its Woolco origin.

27 comments:

  1. The junior anchor you saw in the Belk wing was a Maxway. I don't know what it was before that. That same wing had a Woolworth on the opposite side, which was cut up into some outward-facing stores (Ashley Stewart, West Marine, etc.).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think Macy's bankruptcy "issues" is what kept them from opening up at North Point at around the same time. At NP, Macy's was supposedly going to build a store where Dillard's eventually went. Can you imagine what that mall would be like now if it happened? Given the affluent demographics in the Alpharetta area, that Macy's would probably be a Bloomingdale's now and Saks or Nordstrom would be setting up shop in the old L&T/Belk now. For a mall that's pretty decent, but still less shopped, North Point would probably have a much more opulent feel to it now.

    A little off the topic of Dutch Square, but you brought up an interesting thing with the Macy's situation that I wanted to comment on.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also surprised to find Dutch Square still going; when I went in 2007 it was pretty busy and didn't have many vacancies. It seemed to be a lower-income mall. Thank goodness for Belk- that's a big draw in SC.

    Curious about Tapp's- I drove by the downtown store right before it closed in '95 but never went inside. Upscale like Parisian?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Woolco didn't go bankrupt. It simply wasn't a significant money maker and Woolworth sold off the stores.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Piccadilly was a Morrison's, ate there in 1996 when the family drove to Florida thru the Carolinas to avoid the olympic traffice in Georgia. The mall was pretty empty then, Tapp's sat vacant, as did alot of in-line stores. White's and an Eckards were just about the only things I remember being open.

    ReplyDelete
  6. As always very informative....keep up the stellar work and Happy New Year!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Burlington has only been in this location for around 10 years. They were in Bush River mall after Kroger left. There was a Brindles store after woolco. I think brindles closed in the mid 90s. I don't reacall a spinnakers at Dutch square. I know that Columbiana had one up to 04-05. Could you be thinking of Annabell's it was a two story restaurant in Dutch square and in Columbia mall (columbia place)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you! That was the information I could not find elsewhere. I did not exactly remember the name of the restaurant but thought it was Spinnaker's for some reason. The Burlington issue was confusing to me as well, and I wasn't positive about what was where. I will add this to the corrections I need to make on this and the Richway malls. Where in Dutch Square was Annabell's? I don't see where it could have been...has it been torn out/torn down?

    ReplyDelete
  9. I made numerous corrections on this post. Readers please review :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think the annabell's was just outside of Tapp's. I know the one at Columbia mall was two floors but I can't be sure about the dutch square location. Here's a pretty good write up about it on Columbia closings.
    http://columbiaclosings.com/wordpress/?p=174

    ReplyDelete
  11. Sadly, Cromer's P-Nuts (and it's monkeys!) closed at Dutch Square sometime in the mid-1990s.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The old Brindles may have been subdivided for Burlington and Office Depot, but most of Burlington was formerly a wing of the mall with regular, non-anchor-sized shops. I'm certain this was the wing that contained SCE&G's energy information center; I don't remember the actual name of it, but as a kid, I always stopped in to play with the displays. The one indication of this still standing is the old rear entrance to the mall, in the back parking lot, near the back side entrance of the theater. It's walled up now, being the back wall of Burlington, but there's the obviously different wall and the open space where I believe they now have a dumpster or two sitting.

    ReplyDelete
  13. A year late but I recently finally walked through the mall and found it a little charming to say the least. The Burlington store at Dutch Square is a mess compared to the nice one at Columbia Place but I was impressed by the large Belk store. The Chick-Fil-A, allegedly the oldest in Columbia had recently closed with a new outdoor locale now exists right in front of the mall.

    The mall wasn't dead either the day I went, it was fairly busy with holiday sales and I personally didn't notice too many vacant stores, mostly local stores. It looks nice inside, but I don't think I have any real desire to make return trips to the mall.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This is going to be a difficult mall to turn around, but as long as Belk is there it will hold onto some life. However, I really have my doubts this mall will be alive in 10 years unless by some miracle Macy's gives it another chance. As the oldest functioning mall in the city I wish it could turn around. I think if they could bump BCF into the old Kmart and construct a two-level wing in its place with a new Macy's it would help significantly.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think they should tear down BCF and Office Depot and make a new two story wing with Macy's. They should relocate AMC theatres to an outparcel and turn the old AMC into a new food court complete with the existing Subway, China Max, and Super China Buffet plus a new Villa Pizza, Arby's and Taco Bell.

    ReplyDelete
  16. JT, I'm that kid in the picture of the food court. That was extremely rude of you.

    ReplyDelete
  17. If you've read enough of my blog, I post wisecrack comments on the photos I take as comic relief. Seriously, though, where was your mother?

    ReplyDelete
  18. My ex-neigbors ran the Dutch Square Cromer's!

    I wonder whatever happened to the front facade of the old Barrel of Fun that was located outside of Belk's. I remember spending ALOT of money in that place - it was one of those places where you would get 6 tokens for $1. And I vividly remember the line coming out the door when they got their Ms. Pac-Man machines sometime in late 1981. I still have a token from there, and we moved away from Columbia in 1982!

    I also remember when they Picadilly cafeteria was Morrison's. I hated going there because there was always a 45 minute to hour long wait to get in. But in the end, I always loved the food.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Burlingtion coat factory kind of looks like a dick's.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The A&P is a shoe store now that is located across from the parking lot at Dutch Square. It was never part of the mall. The Annabelle's was across from where Hibbett Sports is in a wing of the mall. Also, the wing of the mall where Woolco was has been made half the length due to Burlington taking over a great deal more space. Also, Tapp's, was located where the AMC theater is now. That end of the mall has been shortened as well to make room for the theater. Just thought you might like to know. dj.hinson@yahoo.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. My oldest son was a baby being pushed in a stroller in a lying down position. He scooted out going up hill in the mall, hit his head. We drove to the Doctors home and had him checked The wonderful late Dr. William Weston. No charge no problems. Your blog really brought back memories. The uphill floor. LOL

    ReplyDelete
  22. I worked on Dutch Square Mall when it was built in 1969. Although the stores and decorations have changed over the years, but the basic mall brings back fine memories of a then young electrician!

    ReplyDelete
  23. I spent my teenage years hanging out with my friends at Dutch Square Mall. It is said watching it die.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Does anyone remember the cool clothing store called Comstock Lode? I think it was on the corner across from the Orange Julius. Awesome 70's clothing!

    ReplyDelete
  25. Whites was originally 2-stories. 3rd story added much later. Outside of Whites in mall was a Radio Shack on right & a pet store on the left. Pet store closed and became Barrel of Fun arcade. Past Radio Shack on right was a clothing store, then Woolworth, then Hallmark store. Past pet store/barrel of fun location on left was a Thom Mcan shoe store, a Britton's clothing store, Cromer's, & another shoe store. At that point on left was a wing with eckerds & morrisons. On right was wing with jewelry store & Rogue hair salon. Past that on right was Lourie's clothing store and on left orange Julius & hickory farms store. A few stores I don't remember, then chick-fil-a on left at corner of next wing interchange. Diagonal from that was a walden's bookstore. Down left wing was a record store and annabell's restaurant. Down right wing was a tobacco shop, clothing store, a Todd n Moore (not original but moved there in late 70s). At end of this wing was Woolco entrance along with side mall entrances. Woolco actually had a diner much like Woolworth, but it was rarely open, and eventually shut down as Woolco struggled. I think Woolco had an automotive dept at end near broad river road.

    Needless to say I spent a lot of time at Dutch square. It was my mom's shopping place. Plus during 70s energy crisis we would go there on hot summer days and hang out since the mall was kept cool.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I opened a Butlers Shoe Store in Dutch Square in 1969. In those days, Dutch Square was the real deal. I raised our son in the back of the store, along with my wife. I have some very fond memories of old Dutch Square. Once upon a time she was the place to shop.

    ReplyDelete